Return of the Cormorants

Bird Island
For Rent, Airy rooms to share, with unmatched ocean and shoreline views! June 2006

In late January, several pairs of Brandt's Cormorants began to build nests on Bird Island, those four curious new structures off Haskell's Beach in Ellwood that replaced the old oil company pier last fall. This was an exciting development, and along with the appearance of Brown Pelicans on the structures in the previous weeks, vindicated several years of effort and the many dollars spent to accommodate the birds using the old Bird Island while removing the remnant of a structure that had become regarded as a risk to public safety. The cormorant nesting colony has continued to grow since January, although for the time being at least, Brown Pelicans have abandoned the cormorant-crowded site as a roost.

By the time the remains of the old pier were destroyed last September and October, it had long gone out of use and had been reduced to a few concrete columns tightly clustered just offshore and connected by some rusty steel beams and part of an old wooden deck. Mostly a curiosity to humans (What is that old thing?), the old pier remnant was a boon to several species of seabirds. This was especially the case for the Brandt's Cormorants that nested there and the endangered California Brown Pelicans that roosted there. These two species more than any other took advantage of the artificial habitat and its isolation from the mainland, taking up residence and crowding around on all the girders, planks, and odd protuberances of the structure. But concerns grew about the dangers to the general public presented by the pier, and talk of taking it down began. The birds' fortuitous use of this monument to human neglect was endangered.

The old pier had seen better days. It dated back to the early 1930s, when it was built as a service structure for the oil wells offshore. Its deterioration is described in the environmental impact report (EIR) prepared by the Ventura firm, Padre Associates, Inc, in 2004: "During the 1950s, as wells were permanently plugged and abandoned, portions of the pier were removed. The remaining offshore well service structure was substantially destroyed during a storm in 1980." The report goes on to predict that the structure, or at least what was left of it, if not soon knocked down by a storm or an earthquake, would give way all on its own.

By the 1990s, the birds had discovered the old pier remnant. Awareness of the pier as a bird roost grew among biologists and birders in the late '90s. A group from the U.S. Geological Survey, doing airplane surveys of seabirds along the coast, first photographed Brandt's Cormorants nesting at that time. Meanwhile, in 1999 a Santa Barbara area birder discovered a Brown Booby here, very rare anywhere in California. Roosting Brown Pelicans by this time seemed a constant presence on the structure, and a few Western and other gulls could be seen there as well.

As concerns grew about the hazards presented by the pier and the liability to which its owner, the British Petroleum/Atlantic Richfield Oil Company (BP/ARCO), was exposed, plans were made to take it down. But during environmental review in 2002, the California Fish and Game Department raised concerns about the loss of habitat for the pelicans and cormorants. Plans were forged to replace the old structure with several that would accommodate the nesting and roosting birds. Santa Barbara Audubon Society commented on the EIR that monitoring was needed to see if the seabirds would use the new structure. The State Lands Commission requested that SBAS develop a monitoring protocol and administer the monitoring aspect of the project. For five years after the structures were erected, SBAS, with funds provided by British Petroleum, will watch the return of the birds to Bird Island.

The four new structures, in their way, are an even greater curiosity than the old pier remnant. Arranged in a line that runs diagonally from the coast just offshore, they each consist of a large column with three triangular platforms, each pointing in a different direction and at a slightly different height, near the top of the columns. A little below the platforms is a narrow circular ledge encompassing each column. An odd sight to be sure, but a welcome sight for the birds looking for a safe place to rest or build a nest.

Bird Island
All four of the nesting structures as they appear offshore of Haskell's Beach, June 2006

The construction of the new Bird Island was completed in December 2005. While a few cormorants were attracted to the structures right away, it was never certain whether birds would really take to them the way they had to the old Bird Island. By the end of December, as many as 79 cormorants had been counted on the structures at one time. This was well below the 200-plus that were sometimes recorded here before construction began in September, but was encouraging nonetheless. What's more, on most days, 15 to 20 endangered California Brown Pelicans were seen every day. At the same time, up to 20 Western and Heermann's Gulls could often be seen among the cormorants and pelicans.

Bird Island
A close up of one of the nesting platforms showing the spiraled 3-tier design. June 2006

Now, the question was whether or not the cormorants would find the new Bird Island a suitable place to build a nest and raise a brood of young. That question appears to have been answered. Cormorants began doing their bowing courtship displays in January, and they were carrying nesting material to Bird Island by the end of the month. As of 3 March 2006, as many as 14 partial or complete nest structures could be seen on the triangular platforms perched high above the water. The cormorants undergo many false starts in nest building, as some nest structures appear and quickly disappear before ever reaching completion. But by early March, as many as five or six nests may have had eggs. This is still far from the roughly 40 Brandt's Cormorant nests counted at times on the old Bird Island, but it's a start, and there's a long way to go in cormorant breeding season.*

At least now we know that while beach walkers may look out at Bird Island and wonder "What are those things?" the birds know very well what they're for. And they can thank Santa Barbara Audubon, who is using science to conserve sensitive bird species along our coast.

Bird Island
A Brandt's Cormorant plunges into the air off one of the platforms. Two other Brandt's Cormorants, sitting on nests, are visible at the platform's edge; June 2006

All photos courtesy, Callie Bowdish.


* By the end of the breeding season, 67 nests had hatched young, nearly twice as many as the 35 that had produced young on the old structure in 2005.

Website information contacts:
Chapter office address:
5679 Hollister Ave., Suite 5b
Goleta, CA 93117
805-964-1468

Chapter email: audubon@rain.org
Website by:
Technical Specialties
©Copyright 2006, Technical Specialties

Updated: October 20, 2006

s